Friday, November 16, 2007

I do not Love Frank

I just finished Loving Frank while on a plane yesterday. Although I really enjoyed Devil in the White City I was pretty ambivalent about reading Loving Frank.

Both are about Chicago, at least sort of, both feature architects and artists, and both have some historical fiction. Seems like my cup of tea, right? WRONG.

You see, I actually have an issue with books. It's one that I'm a little embarassed about, because I feel like it makes me seem immature, naive, and unworldly. And here it is: I actually can't get that into books whose protagonists do things that I don't approve of. I couldn't feel sorry for Frank and Mamah because they were both adulterers. Their spouses weren't abusive, cared for them, and their lives were nice. They both selfishly left home and family in the pursuit of "happiness."

I just can't get behind that. I couldn't feel bad for them, no matter the censure they recieved because a) they were adulters and fairly irresponsible, leaving others to clean up their mess at home, and b) they KNEW what would happen. Frank was well-known and Mamah well-respected in their community. It should have come as no surprise that they'd be shunned and censured. Does it suck? Yes. But it isn't shocking.

I did manage to cry at the end anyway (I won't tell you why, it'll ruin the book--although Pedant believes, and I sort of agree, that you can't ruin historically-based books because presumably the story is common knowledge), but I didn't love the book. There were some interesting feminist and philosophical ideas (Mamah Cheney was apparently friends with Ellen Key) but it mostly felt like a whiny "the world is against us, boo-hoo."

In conclusion, my book club sucks at picking books, we totally should have read Peony in Love.


Tamar said...

Okay, here are some books to read in your book club that definitely don't suck. First, Long May She Reign by Ellen Emerson White. Kicks ASS. I also loved a book called Falling in Love With Natassia by Anna Monardo, though I think it's probably kind of hard to find. The Remains of the Day is amazing, and has a lot of different layers to it, so it would be great for discussion. Another good one, though somewhat dense, is Smilla's Sense of Snow. Finally, I'm reading Julie and Julia now, a book about a cooking blog that's actually really fantastic. Anyway, I bet you'll like any of these more than you don't like Frank.

Annie said...

I think that the really problem is that I am not so enamored of the club, either.

Anonymous said...

You might not find as many ball gowns prom dresses in discount wedding party dresses black but there are so many other styles in black it could make your head go round. discount wedding shop Black prom dresses are often decorated with discount wedding shops